Toilet Flappers

Korky 54BP Toilet Tank Flapper

Fluidmaster K-400H-039 Fill Valve and Flapper Repair Kit

A two-in-one fix for a running or slow-filling 2-inch-valve toilet, replacing the fill valve and flapper together instead of guessing which part failed.

Korky 3060BP Large Toilet Flapper 3 Inch

A straightforward 3 inch flapper replacement for chlorine tablet users, worth it once you've confirmed the 3 inch opening.

Korky 100BP Ultra High Performance Toilet Flapper 2 Inch

A basic, high-volume 2 inch flapper replacement for a standard tank, best used as a like-for-like swap.

Kohler GP85160 Toilet Flapper with Float 2 Inch

The right replacement only when your toilet's model number falls in Kohler's listed range, since this is a model-matched OEM part rather than a generic fit.

TOTO THU500S Replacement Flapper 3 Inch

Go with this only after matching your existing flapper's part number against TOTO's compatibility list, since it's built for specific TOTO tanks rather than as a universal 3 inch part.

KOHLER K-GP84995 Hinge Toilet Flapper 2 Inch

Correct only for the specific Kohler one-piece models it lists, not a general-purpose 2-inch flapper substitute.

Fluidmaster 502 Universal Toilet Flapper 3-Pack

A well reviewed universal 2 inch flapper pack with genuine water-saving adjustment, a sensible default pick before hunting for a brand-specific part.

Fluidmaster 502P21 PerforMAX Universal Toilet Flapper 2 Inch

A straightforward fix for a running 2-inch-valve toilet, with a dial that lets you adjust flush volume instead of settling for whatever the old flapper gave you.

Fluidmaster 5403 Universal Toilet Flapper 3 Inch

A solid pick for a 3-inch valve toilet with a degraded stock flapper, given the silicone seal's longer rated life over standard rubber.

American Standard VorMax Toilet Flapper Assembly 7381657-200.0070A

iFealClear Toilet Flapper for Gerber 99-788 3 Inch

A targeted fix for a leaking Gerber 99-788 flapper, but confirm the 3 inch opening and attachment arm spacing before buying since it's not a universal part.

Hibbent Large Toilet Flapper for Gerber 99-788 3 Inch

A straightforward 3-inch flapper for Gerber 99-788 style tanks. Confirm your valve opening measures 3 inches before ordering.

KOHLER GP1078440 Shark-Fin Toilet Flapper

A genuine Kohler shark-fin flapper for a set list of one-piece toilets. It will not fit other brands or models, so confirm your toilet model first.

Kohler GP83064 Flapper for One-Piece Toilets

A genuine Kohler flapper with chain for a long list of older one-piece toilets. It fits only the listed models, so match your model number first.

Korky 2017BP Long-Life Toilet Flapper 2 Inch

A durability-focused 2 inch flapper for households whose water or chlorine tablets chew through standard rubber flappers quickly.

KOHLER GP1078441 Flapper for Two-Piece Toilets

A genuine Kohler flapper for two-piece Class Five toilets across several popular lines. Confirm your tank model, since the part is model-specific.

Lydia's Deal RXZER1 Toilet Flapper 2 Pack

Two red rubber flappers sized for 2-inch flush valves, worth it once you've confirmed that's your valve size and want a spare in reserve.

Winonly Universal Toilet Flapper 2 Inch

A capable 2-inch flapper that lives up to its cross-brand claims once you confirm valve size first. Skip it if you haven't measured.

Mansfield 630-0207 Toilet Flapper

A simple rubber flapper for fixing a running toilet without tools. Fit claims conflict, so check the flush valve size before buying.

American Standard Universal Flapper and Chain with Float

KOHLER GP1039444 Flapper for One-Piece Toilets

A genuine Kohler flapper for specific one-piece Class Five toilets. Check the tank number inside the tank before buying, since it fits only the listed models.

Lecyco Toilet Flapper for Gerber 99-788 2 Pack

A 2-pack rubber flapper replacement sized for Gerber 99-788 and other 3-inch flush valve toilets, sold with two spare toilet handle chains for the next repair.

Fluidmaster 400ARHRFCS PerforMAX Toilet Repair Kit